How To Make Cookies On The Traeger

Imagine a world where you can combine the flavor of fresh baked cookies with the wood fired flavor of the Traeger.  Well that world exists, and soon enough it will exist in your backyard.  Enjoy this fun recipe for our Kitchen Sink Cookies or our Kitchen Sink Cookie Skillet.

How To Make Cookies On The Traeger

PRINT RECIPE HERE: Traeger Kitchen Sink Cookie


Yield: 2 Dozen Cookies

Prep time: 10 Minute Prep

Total time: 16-18 Minutes Cook Time, depending on desired doneness


Measure   Ingredient                                            

½ Pound       Butter, Unsalted - room temp softened

¾ Cup            Sugar, Brown, Dark - packed

1 Cup             Sugar, White, Cane, Granulated

2 ea                Eggs, Whole, Fresh, XLARGE                           

1 Tbsp            Vanilla Paste or Vanilla Extract                         

2 ½ Cups       Flour, White, All Purpose                                   

1 tsp                Salt, Kosher                        

1 tsp                Baking Soda                                               

½ Cup            Pecans, Pieces      

½ Cup            Pretzels, DOTS - crushed                   

2 Cups           Chocolate Chips, Milk      

1 Cup             Chocolate Chips, Semi Sweet or White

1 Cup             M&M’s, Plain

Cooking Directions

  • Preheat Traeger Irownood 885 to 400 Degrees, bring bottom shelf up to the second level
  • Cream butter with both sugars
  • Add eggs, 1 by 1, then vanilla paste, mix well
  • Mix flour, salt and baking soda together in large bowl
  • Add flour mixture to eggs and butter
  • Mix until coming off of walls of mixing bowl.  Scrape side and bottom of bowl if needed
  • Add chocolate chips, white chocolate chips, m&m’s, pecans and crushed dots pretzels.  Mix until just combined.  Scrape Bowl and paddle if needed
  • Scoop using #24 scoop, or large tablespoon, packed full and rounded off.  Make into a puck
  • FREEZE for 2 hours before baking
  • Arrange 8 cookies per Traeger Grill Pan or heavy duty cookie sheet tray
  • Bake at 400° for approx 8 minutes, rotate and bake until desired doneness is reached
  • Soft Cookies (approx another 7-8 minutes)
  • Crispy Cookies (approx. another 9-10 minutes)
  • Remove from pan and cool on a rack
  • store covered, once completely cooled

Products Used


For more tips, go to

Published: 3/2/2020